Review Article - (2020) Volume 5, Issue 2
López MLP*
Department of Urology, “Virgendel Rocío” Hospital & University, Spain
Received Date: March 29, 2020; Accepted Date: April 15, 2020; Published Date: April 22, 2020
Citation: López MLP (2020) Emphysematous Pyelonephritis: Case Series and Review of the Literature. Insights Biomed Vol.5 No.2:4. DOI: 10.36648/2572-5610.5.2.69
Introduction: Emphysematous pyelonephritis (EPN) is a rare gas-forming infection of renal parenchyma and excretory system and surrounding renal areas. It has a low incidence but high mortality (15-20%).
Objectives: Our goal is to report our series of EPN and review the literature about this entity to improve its management.
Materials and Methods: We analyze three EPN cases, in our Centre from 2017 to 2019, two women and one man between 45-84-years-old. Common symptoms were pain and fever with fatal evolution to septic shock in one of them. Medical management was adopted in all of them. Percutaneous nephrostomy was needed in two cases to complete treatment. And one case of dry type EPN required an urgent nephrectomy. Escherichia coli was isolated in all cases. Mortality rate reached 33.3%.
Discussion and Conclusion: EPN is a rare and severe necrotizing infection of renal parenchyma and its surrounding areas. It appears most commonly in females (6: 1). Diabetes mellitus is the main risk factor and urinary obstruction occurs in 25- 40%. Escherichia coli is isolated in 70%. There are many classifications to establish the best treatment according to stage. The most complete is Huang and Tseng classification (2000), based on CT radiological findings. Systolic pressure <90 mmHg, thrombocytopenia, bilateral EPN are associated with poor prognosis. Early medical treatment is essential. The most accepted management consist of support measures with percutaneous nephrostomy. In not-responding patients and those with bad prognosis, urgent nephrectomy can be necessary.
Emphysematous pyelonephritis; Percutaneous drainage; Conservative management
Pyelonephritis emphysematous (PNE) is a necrotizing infection characterized by gas within renal parenchyma, urinary system and perinephric tissues [1,2]. This entity has a low incidence but high mortality even more than 15-20% 3]. The objective is to show the series in our Centre from 2017 to 2019 and review the literature about PNE to improve and homogenize its management.
Medical history: A 45-years-old woman who suffers from hypertension and non-controlled Type II Diabetes Mellitus history.
Symptoms: She presented a severe constitutional syndrome and pain on left renal fossa. She also developed high fevers at home (40ºC).
Examination: General examination showed bad general condition, with neurologic impairment (Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS 8), hemodynamic instability with blood pressure (BP) of 87 /51 mmHg, tachycardia (110 bpm), tachypnea (20 bpm) and hypothermia (32.8°)
Initial complementary tests: Urine sample showed ketones and leucocyturia. Bloodcount obtained leucocytosis (40.000 cel/mm3), neutrophilia 80% and normal platelets. Biochemistry identified high creatinine levels (2.47 mg/dl), hypokalaemia (3 mEq/L) and glycaemia 600 mg/dl, severe metabolic acidosis (pH 6.9 and bicarbonate, 10.1 mEq / L, Lactic Acid 6 mmol/L) and high acute phase reactants levels (C reactive protein 420 mg/l).
Initial clinical judgment: The initial diagnosis was a diabetic ketoacidosis event according to her medical history.
Treatment: Firstly, we combined fluids: 3500 cc-physiological saline+ 500 cc-volume expansor such as Gelofusinewith intravenous insulin therapy (24UI), bicarbonate 1/6M (250 cc) and potassium chloride (20 mEq/l) and empirical antibiotic therapy (Ciprofloxacin 400 mg IV).
Evolution: The evolution was torpid towards septic shock with apnoea pauses and pulseless electrical activity with need for orotracheal intubation and advanced cardio-pulmonary reanimation manoeuvres. Once she was stabilized in the Intensive Care Unit (ICU), several imaging techniques were performed:
Abdominal US: A slight amount of free peritoneal liquid and inability to visualize the left kidney due to gas interposition. Taking into account of these findings we decided to extend the image study with a CT.
Contrast-enhanced abdominal CT: A CT showed a severe left emphysematous pyelonephritis with venous thrombosis and a moderate amount of free peritoneal liquid (Figures 1 and 2).
Figure 1: Emphysematous pyelonephritis grade IIIa with gas in urinary system, parenchyma and perinephric gas.
Figure 2: Gas and venous thrombosis.
Diagnosis: Emphysematous pyelonephritis grade IIIa according to radiological classification because there was perinephric gas.
Definitive management: In the absence of urinary obstruction that had permitted percutaneous access, clinical evolution and fatal prognostic factors, urgent open left nephrectomy was decided.
Evolution: At ICU, patient remained on mechanical ventilation in a controlled volume mode, 40% FiO2, 16 bpm and 100% oxygen saturation. She stayed under sedation with morphic chloride 0.5 mg/h. The antibiotic was changed to Meropenem 1 g/8h IV.
Patient needed initially, Noradrenaline (NA) 0.55 mcg/kg/min to maintain blood pressure above 80/50 mmHg and also required continuous venous hemofiltration at 250 ml/min with volume replacement of 2500 ml/h and extraction of 500 ml/h associated with treatment with heparin 5 UI/kg/h.
After surgery, hemodynamic and renal function improvement was achieved although neurological prognosis (GSC 4; E1V1M2) was poor with hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy and absence of cortical response.
A decrease of NA doses was possible from 0.55 to 0,05 mcg/kg/ min in next 24 hours.
Blood count obtained a significant improvement in leucocytosis (40.000 cel/mm3→14.000 cel/mm3), neutrophilia (80% → 74%) and thrombocytosis (541.000 cel/mm3). Biochemistry identified a significant improvement in creatinine levels (2.47 mg/dl→1,32 mg/dl) and ions (K 3.5 mEq/l).
A neuroelectrophysiological study was performed showing isoelectric tracing without cortical reactivity to nociceptive stimuli, which in the absence of sedative medication is concordant with absence of brain activity and the neuroelectrophysiological study, a study of somesthetic evoked potentials was carried out with no corticalresponses anddiencephalic injury. So, unfavorable outcomes were expected. Unfortunately, patient died at the thirteenth day in the ICU.
Medical history: A 69-year-old man diagnosed and treated of hypertension, hemispheric stroke and smoking habits. He underwent left hernioplasty 2 years ago.
Symptoms: He was admitted on Neurology ward on suspicion of right ischemic stroke with left hemiparesis and dysarthria with neurologic impairment (GCS 10).
He suffered from abdominal pain since two days. Pain was located on left renal fossa and irradiating to the left inguinal region. He also had diarrhoea and maintained febricula with evening high fevers as high as 38.5ºC.
Examination: He presented a poor general condition, neurologic impairment (Glasgow 12), eupneic, hemodynamically stable with BP 130/80 mmHg, tachycardia (120 bpm). The temperature was 37.7ºC.
Initial complementary tests: Urine Sample showed leucocituria and microscopic haematuria. Blood count obtained leucocytosis (41,000 cel/mm3) and neutrophilia 89%. Biochemistry showed high levels of Creatinine (2.7 mg/dl) and high acute phase reactants levels (C reactive protein 375 mg/l). No significant alterations in venous gasometry were found.
In Neurology ward a Head CT had been permormed and the results were inconclusive with hypodense areas in right basal ganglia suggestive of lacunar infarcts versus dilated Virchow- Robin spaces. Initial clinical judgment is right hemispheric stroke. Fever is without diagnosed focus.
Evolution: Persistence of fever and elevation of reactants of acute phase that guide an infectious context. Because of that, we performed an abdominal ultrasound and any pathological findings were founded.
Finally, the abdominal CT revealed a left pyeloureteritis with gas in the urinary system and slight ureterohydronephrosis secondary to millimetre lithiasis (5mm) in the left distal ureter (Figures 3 and 4).
Figure 3: PNE grade I with gas only in the excretory system.
Figure 4: Lithiasis located in the left distal ureter.
Diagnosis: Emphysematous pyelonephritis grade I according to radiological classification so there was gas only in the excretory system.
Definitive management: fluid therapy with 1500cc-physiological saline, empirical antibiotic therapy with intravenous Piperacillin/ Tazobactam 4 g/0.5 g three times a day and urgent urinary diversion through ultrasound (US)-guided left percutaneous nephrostomy 8Fr × 26 cm. Escherichia coli was the isolated agent in blood and urine samples.
Evolution: We modified the antbiotic therapy to AmoxicilinClavulanic Acid 1g/8h, 3 days after, when the urine culture results showed a mutisensible Escherichia coli. The clinical evolution was satisfactory without fever after urinary derivation and antibiotics tehrapy. We kept the intravenous antibiotic for 2 days longer until the blood test normalized (leucocytosis, CRP and Creatinine). Patient was discharged 5 days later with the same oral antibiotic treatment during 2 weeks. After acute episode, patient was prepared to left semi-rigid ureteroscopy to remove the distal ureter lithiasis and the nephrostomy tube was removed 24 hours after surgery.
Medical history: A 84-year-old woman who suffered from hypertension, dyslipidaemia, atrial fibrillation, hypertensive heart disease and severe aortic stenosis.
Symptoms: She presented haematuria associated with abdominal pain on the right renal fossa. She also started with high fever up to 38ºC two days after the pain appeared.
Examination: Bad general condition with impaired neurological status (Glasgow 10). Hemodynamically stable (BP 120 / 70 mmHg, FC 90 lpm). Tachypnea (28 bpm). Temperature was 37ºC.
Initial complementary tests: Elemental urine showed leucocyturia and microscopic haematuria. Blood count obtained neutrophilia (87%) without leucocytosis (11.000 cell/mm3) and normal platelets. Biochemistry showed levels slightly high of creatinine (Cr 1.5 mg/dl) and high acute phase reactants levels (C reactive protein 280 mg/l) with metabolic acidosis (pH 7.2, bicarbonate, 18.1 mEq / L and Lactic Acid 4 mmol/L) and high acute phase reactants levels (C reactive protein 420 mg/l).
Initial clinical judgment: Right acute pyelonephritis.
Evolution: The evolution developed towards septic shock that required Intensive Cares. An abdominal ultrasound was performance, which described emphysematous pyelitis with pyonephrosis and gas in the right renal pelvis with moderate hydronephrosis.
Diagnosis: Emphysematous pyelonephritis grade I.
Definitive management: She was managed in the ICU with supportive measures and empirical intravenous antibiotic was started with Ceftriaxone 2g (charge dose) and Ceftriaxone 1 g/24 h as well as urgent urinary diversion through right US-guided percutaneous nephrostomy 8Fr × 26 cm. Escherichia coli was the isolated agent in blood and urine samples.
Patient needed initially, Noradrenaline (NA) 0.1 mcg/kg/min to maintain blood pressure above 90/60 mmHg and fluids 2500 ccphysiological saline.
After antibiotics therapy and urinary derivation, a progressive decrease of NA doses was possible in 24 hrs. Blood count obtained a significant improvement in neutrophilia (87% → 75%) and Biochemistry identified a normalization in creatinine levels (1.50 mg/dl → 0.90 mg/dl) and CRP values (420 mg/l 320 mg/l and also venous gasometry improvement was detected (pH 7.33, bicarbonate, 20 mEq/L and Lactic Acid 1 mmol/l).
Evolution: Patients was stabilized for 48 hours in the ICU with excellent evolution.
A control CT scan was performed, showing only signs of right pyelitis. No obstructive causes were identified. After clinical and analytical normalization, discharge was decided on the seventh day. We modified the antbiotic therapy to Amoxicilin Clavulanic Acid 1 g/8 h, 3 days after, when the urine culture results showed a mutisensible Escherichia coli. We kept the intravenous antibiotic 2 days longer until the blood test normalized (neutrophilia, CRP levels). Finally, patient was discharged 2 days later with the same oral antibiotic treatment during 2 weeks.
PNE is a life-threatening necrotizing bacterial infection with gas in the excretory system, parenchyma, or perinephric space [1,2]. Its incidence is low but it presents a high mortality. Its maximum incidence is around the 5th-6th decade of life, being predominantly in female (6: 1) due to a higher incidence of UTIs in women [2].
Poorly controlled Diabetes Mellitus (DM) is the most frequent (around 100%) associated risk factor because glucosuria allows the growth of glucose-fermenting bacterias that could leads to infection with gas formation [3,4]. Urinary tract obstruction underlies 25-40% [3]. Other known risk factors are nephrolithiasis, age, previous UTI, alcoholism, inmmunosupresion, end stage renal disease and polycystic kidneys although without statistical significance for increased mortality [3,5]. Furthermore, there are poor prognostic factors such as systolic blood pressure <90 mmHg, thrombocytopenia, >50% renal parenchymal destruction, disturbed level of consciousness, bilaterality or single kidney afected, venous thrombosis and renal failure [3-6].
The most frequent etiologic agent is Escherichia coli (70%) [2,4,7]. Because as Escherichia coli, Klebsiella pneumoniae, Proteus mirabilis and as Pseudomonas aeruginosa, can ferment glucose to produce gas, predominantly carbondioxide [7,8]. About physiopathology factors, hyperglycaemia, renal blood flow decrease and secondary ischemia, immunosuppression or obstructive uropathy may be key factors involved [4,7].
Non-specific symptoms such as fever and abdominal pain are the commonest clinical presentation, nausea, and vomiting with laboratory abnormalities (elevation of acute phase reactants and creatinine levels) are also frequent [4]. The diagnosis is suspected and requires a confirmatory imaging test. Ultrasonography, and mainly CT, detects the presence of gas, being the choice for its greater sensitivity and assessment of the severity [3].
There are multiple classifications to establish the management based on the PNE type [1,3]. The most complete is Huang and Tseng classifications from 2000 based on radiological findings: (I) Gas in excretory system, only; (II) Gas in parenchyma, only; (IIIa) Perinephric extension; (IIIb) Paranephric extension; (IV) PNE in single or bilateral kidney [3]. This classification has a prognosis value and it could be a clinical tool to plannify the optimal treatment according the severity [4,9,10].
The presence of venous thrombosis is a rare presentation of emphysematous pyelonephritis such as occurs in our Case number 1 with renal vein thromobosis in CT findings [5]. It could be possible because sepsis is a prothrombotic state owing to impairment of all antithrombotic pathways [5,11].
Firstly, we should to take into account that some published studies shows that 50% of patients in Intensive Care Units suffer from disseminated intravascular coagulation complications [12]. So, there is a clear relationship between inflammation, coagulation system and sepsis. Both, inflammation and coagulation works together so thrombi constitute the first-line immune defense in vasculatory system and it is the base of immunothrombosis named by Engelmann et al. [13]. However, systemic thrombosis status because of disseminated intravascular coagulation increases the organ dysfunction and doubles death risk in sepsis [11,13,14].
In this way, it is known that monocytes, macrophages and platelets activate the coagulation system but neutrophil are also involved in these pathways [15].
Platelets recruitment leuckocytes during the sepsis episode, so, they are consumed because of the platelet-leuckocyte complex formation. These conjugates induce proinflammatory events for adhering to the endothelium, generating disturbances in microcirculation. This concept is related to the endotheliopathy [11,16,17] that occurs during the sepsis with the endogenous catecholamines production and the secondary endothelium disruption and endothelial cells injuries.
Anaemiais frequently seen in sepsis patients because of the accelerated apoptosis-like of red cells from circulating blood [11,18]. Erythrocytes are also involved in these immunothrombotic events because they can attract bacterias and fixes them to the erythrocyte’s surface to be ingested and killed [19]. Recent studies have reported that erythrocytes suffer from eryptosisor erythrocyto’s death, when they are infected or nonfunctional and then they keep adhered to endothelium forming clots with immunological functions. But after that, hemoproteins (hem) could have a bactericid role within the immunothrombin or prothrombotic effects if they are free circulating through the blood stream [11,20,21]. Initial management of EPN consists of support measures, fluids (saline, volume expansors), and empirical antibiotic therapy (broad-spectrum antibiotics) [4]. After medical treatment, specific conservative measures, a percutaneous approach and urinary diversion are proposed, preserving the renal unit by 70% without increasing mortality [4,9,10].
In published meta-analyses, the most successful strategy were support measures associated with the percutaneous approach with lower mortality rates (13.5%) (P<0.0001) [2]. Using the Huang and Tseng classification with less than two risk factors, they would benefit from support measures with or without percutaneous diversion, while with more than two risk factors and they require more aggressive measures such as emergency nephrectomy(3). Literature supports that I, II had an excellent prosgnosis even without stent insertion althout catheters are necessary if urinary obstruction exists. On the other hand, nephrectomy is usually needed in III group if there is no response to conservative measures [3,4,9,10,22,23].
In our series, the diabetes rate was 34%. The mortality rate was 34% and the causative agent was Escherichia coli in 100% of the cases. The management chosen in each case was urgent nephrectomy in case 1, as it was a dry Type of emphysematous pyelonephritis and a percutaneous approach in the remaining two with good evolution.
In conclusion, we must know that PNE is an entity that, although infrequent, is a life-threatening disease, usually associated with poorly controlled DM. it requires clinical suspicion and imaging test, preferably CT, to confirm the diagnosis. Initial and early support measures are essential. Nowadays, the most widely accepted treatment is medical management associated with percutaneous diversion. In non-responders or in cases of poor prognosis, urgent nephrectomy may be necessary.
